Fast forward to this year, I wanted to do the same thing but the laptop with the publisher files I had created last year on it died about a week ago. I could have sworn I had saved everything to Dropbox, but I guess I must have been in a hurry (imagine that) and probably told myself I'd do it after the holidays (and we all know that is a black hole worse than "I'll do it tomorrow")
So after re-creating it again this year, I thought I'd post it here so that others could benefit and I can always find it.
I printed it on plain white paper and included a cut line for where to trim. Just wrap it around the popcorn and tape in place. Then place a pair of magic gloves as the hat and tie some ribbon on it. Here's the finished product.